By Grace Vuoto
What went wrong? President Donald Trump soared to power in 2024, securing control of the House and Senate, winning the support of more than 77 million voters. Yet, the 2026 midterm elections were a resounding rebuke. Democrats won large majorities in both the House and Senate, leaving Trump’s coalition and party in shambles. He suffered among the largest midterm repudiations in American history.
The verdict has been delivered: the American people have rejected the president’s economic and foreign policy. Given his overall low approval numbers, it is also clear they disapprove of his tone and style of governance.
The second Trump term failed to deliver on a key campaign promise: lowering the cost of living. In January 2025, the public expected relief as soon as possible. Yet, none was forthcoming, as lower taxes and deregulation were put on the back burner. Instead, April 2, 2025, was the Day of Destruction not “Liberation Day” as the president called it. He unleashed a bizarre, half-baked global trade war that was the equivalent of a wrecking ball to the American economy. He sought to remake a 40-year economic structure overnight. Millions of his own voters had their lives upended by a tariff regime that was both foolish and reckless.
Trump compounded this error with never-ending vacillations: tariffs imposed, raised, lowered, removed — cavalierly, without regard for the impact on the livelihood of the American people. He shifted tariffs 50 times since he imposed them, making it impossible for businesses to plan. By contrast, during his entire first term there were only 12 tariff adjustments, a reasonable amount. This time, he remained indifferent to the impact his ceaseless tariff jockeying had on his very own supporters.
As a result, across the Farm Belt and Rust Belt, in deep red states, the GOP was trounced. In addition, due to the lack of consumer certainty and confidence in the economic trajectory, investors took a “wait and see” attitude, freezing the real estate market. This was further compounded by interest rates that remained high due to stubborn inflation. Thus, the real estate market has had its worst two years in decades. Homeowners and buyers are mostly immobile. Hundreds of thousands of realtors are leaving the profession altogether. According to the well-known adage, “as goes real estate, so does the rest of the economy.”
Finally, the One Big Beautiful Bill was passed in July 2025, with much-needed tax and regulatory relief—but this would take time to provide benefits, and time started to run out. On February 20, the Supreme Court shot down the shoddy tariff regime, dealing a devastating blow to an already incomprehensible structure. The federal government was forced to repay tens of billions of dollars to business owners whom the court ruled had been taxed illegally. What a mess.
The economic debacle was mirrored in foreign policy. Trump promised to bring peace between Russia and Ukraine, peace in the Middle East and not to start new wars. He failed to deliver in each of these vital arenas, while breaking key campaign promises.
Regarding Russia and Ukraine, at the outset, Trump’s foreign policy team stated that they would either get a deal or “walk away.” Thus, they signaled to Russian President Vladimir Putin that he could wait them out. Trump was sympathetic to Russian fears of Ukraine joining NATO and initially pressured Ukraine to back down. Then, suddenly, Trump went back on his campaign pledge and decided to continue sending arms to Ukraine (although making the European Union buy the arms from the US). At the same time, he negotiated a mineral deal between the Ukraine and the US that would put American business interests on Russia’s doorsteps, thus threatening Russia just as much as the prospect of Ukraine entering NATO.
Whose side is America on in this conflict? No one knows, not even Trump. At times he is sympathetic to Russia, and at times, he is amenable to Ukraine. For almost two years, there has been no foreign policy but a series of temperamental maneuvers, antagonizing both nations, as the war smolders on.
The president also failed to bring peace to the Middle East. There, all he needed to do was support Israel and allow that nation’s capable leaders to devise the best methods for their self-defense. Instead, he meddled and interfered incessantly. In June 2025, he launched Operation Midnight Hammer, which his team declared had “obliterated” Iran’s nuclear program — until we were told in February that Iran was suddenly “two weeks” away from a nuclear weapon. The president’s credibility was shattered: either he lied in June or he was lying in February. Both facts cannot be true.
Another campaign promise was blatantly broken when Trump started the Iran war. This one began without a mandate, without congressional authorization, without the support of Trump’s closest advisors and without public support. He and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth were the two major warmongers who wanted to proceed. The Iranians retaliated by closing the Strait of Hormuz — a response that was easy to predict. This resulted in one of the most humiliating moments in our nation’s military history. A regional power was elevated to global influence: Iran now held the world’s oil supply hostage and controlled the gas and grocery prices of every American.
In a parliamentary system, this kind of error in judgment and poor planning would have led to a no-confidence vote and the immediate collapse of the government.
The president didn’t swiftly fire his inept Defense Secretary (who shouldn’t have been appointed in the first place due to his lack of credentials for the job) for the failure to prevent the closure of the Strait of Hormuz. Instead, Trump attacked members of his own antiwar base, feuding publicly with the very voters and influencers who had championed his America First platform for over 10 years. Suddenly, he branded them “pathetic” and “losers.”
So, what is MAGA 2.0? What does it stand for? Trump willy-nilly throws members out of the movement based on his own whimsical interpretations. Yet, many of those voters stand firmly on the very principles for which he was the most formidable champion. Where did their champion go? And who are his constituents now?
A similar pattern of reversals and betrayals ensued with the release of the Epstein files. Instead of transparency and bringing to justice wealthy pedophiles who had violated more than 1,000 young girls, then-Attorney General Pam Bondi and her then-Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche covered up the evidence. They were following the president’s orders to do so.
Trump blasted his own supporters, telling them this was a “hoax” and he didn’t need their votes. He vilified the courageous Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, called her a “traitor” and unleashed a campaign of hate against her. To add insult to injury, convicted pedophile and Epstein girlfriend, Ghislaine Maxwell, was moved to a more comfortable prison, casting more suspicion on the Trump administration.
Thus, Trump’s team reneged on his promise to restore the credibility of the Justice Department. The Swamp lives on.
Amidst these stinging betrayals and mistakes, Trump adorned the White House with gold. He became disconnected from the needs of the “forgotten men and women” who are struggling; he drifted far from American republican traditions of modesty. Our White House is unique and glorious because of its humility and simplicity. He missed the mark completely on the public mood — and the optics are terrible.
For two years, Trump has lacked focus. Most of the first year was spent on chasing the Noble Peace Prize and foreign policy adventures. He also decided to build a lavish ballroom for the Washington and global elite. No one elected him for construction projects. Yet, he is obsessed with fixing the Reflecting Pool, building the Triumphal Arch and putting his name on the Kennedy Center. The pragmatic businessman of the first term is long gone. Instead, there is this out-of-touch, grasping multibillionaire pursuing extravagant projects, full of pride and vainglory.
In essence, the first three years of MAGA 1.0 (before the pandemic) brought peace and prosperity. The first two years of MAGA 2.0 have brought economic chaos, high prices, war continuing to rage between Russia and Ukraine and wars in the Middle East even larger than when he took office. In the meantime, due to constant vacillations in domestic and foreign policy, Trump’s credibility and likeability have evaporated — leading to abysmal approval ratings heading into the midterm elections.
Sadly, during the second term, Trump has morphed into another Washington, DC creature. He is no longer the savvy, competent businessman who brings prosperity, stays out of foreign entanglements and talks straight. He is now the very type of leader he once ridiculed: a globalist, an incompetent and shifty politician.
It is no wonder the American people have removed key levers of power from his grasp. Unless Trump returns quickly to MAGA 1.0, his future and legacy will be grim.
-Grace Vuoto, Ph.D. is a political commentator and columnist. She can be heard Wednesday mornings at 9:00 am on The Kuhner Report WRKO-AM 680. She is also the co-host of The Conversation With Stephen and Grace WXTK 95.1 FM on Saturdays from 11 am to 1 pm.

